MIRI:
Jag jobbar som fotograf, främst reklam och mode. vi har två apple 23 tums skärmar som är något år gamla. vi har aldrig haft några bättre skärmar, då har vi haft en hel del skärmar och bytit ofta.
vi har t ex skickat över 300 produktbilder till tryck utan att efter provtryck behöva göra en enda färgjustering.
det anser jag är fruktansvärt bra.
Nu kostar en 23 tums apple skärm 11 996 kr om du kan dra momsen. Det anser jag är oerhört prisvärt.
men smaken är ju olika. man kan ju köpa en barko-skärm om man vill, det är om något kvalitet.
Jag har nu kollat både 20" och 23" . Mätt upp dom med extern kalibrator och därefter visuellt tittat på en gråskala. Ingen, reperar ingen av skärmarna uppfyller de krav man bör och skall kräva av en bildskärm och arbetet med foto. Fula bandningar, gråskala i rött,grönt, rosa.
Ingen av skärmarna kom i närheten av de mätvärden som kalibratorn eftersträvar vad det gäller ljus/ kontrast värde.
Ingen av skärmarna kan uppvisa botten svärta.
Att du sedan tycker skärmen är bra , det är din uppfattning om hur en skärm skall bete sig
Mikael
bilden illustrerar bandning och grönskifte från en 20" skärm.
Skapa en gråskala från vitt till svart så kan du se hur din skärm uppträder.
Sänder även med vad Barefeats skriver :
ARE YOUR BLACKS BLACK AND GRAYS GRAY?
I have read complaints about the grays in the Apple 23" Cinema looking pinkish and the blacks are really dark gray. We hooked up both displays simultaneously to our G5's X800 XT. We went to the Desktop & Screen Saver tile in System Preferences and selected the first Desktop image in "Black & White" folder called "Lightning." The Dell 24" was truly black at the bottom of the image. The 23" Cinema was dark gray. We selected the Flurry screen saver and clicked Test. The 24" Dell was black in the background while the 23" Cinema was dark gray.
We went back to Desktop images and selected the second image in "Black & White" called "Mojave" which had a lot of gray especially at the top. The Dell 24" was gray while the 23" Cinema had a pinkish hue along the top edge. We selected the Apple Image called "Jaguar Aqua Graphite" (third row). The 23" Cinema showed a definite pinkish hue along the top and left of the screen while the 24" Dell was gray all over. We created a 1920x1200 light gray image in Photoshop CS2. It had a pinkish hue all over it on the 23" Cinema, especially around the edges. The 24" Dell displayed a uniform gray all over its screen.
These anomalies were observed when I was helping the San Diego Supercomputer evaluate the 23" and 30" Cinemas for their Visualization Lab. They use their screens to display intricate scientific simulations where color, brightness, contrast, and hue are very important. At one point, we turned off all the lights in the lab to see if the black screen was truly black. It wasn't. They described it as "backlight leakage." They rejected the Cinema displays as a serious contenders in their search for the ultimate LCD display for their lab. They were disappointed since they loved the "loook and feel" of the Apple Cinema displays -- especially the 30 incher.
When they heard about the 24" Dell, they called me to ask what I thought. I informed them that I had ordered one the day before. After testing it, I've encouraged them to give it serious consideration and offered to bring mine to their lab for a trial.
23" CINEMA HAS ITS ADVANTAGES
I have to give Apple's 23" Cinema its due. It does have a better dot pitch at .25 vs .27. It has both FireWire and USB 2.0 ports.
And it looks sexier on your desk with the thin, smooth anodized aluminum bezel and curved stand. Dell chose a "midnight" gray plastic bezel with silver on the edges and stand. I suppose it is as attractive as plastic can look but the Apple Cinema makes better desk "sculpture."
